Having a job isn't enough: why underpaid work still counts as unemployment in India
A new analysis argues that India's jobs picture looks better on paper than on the ground, with underemployment, rural shifts and gender gaps hiding real hardship.

A new opinion analysis argues that India's employment story has a blind spot. Holding a job is not the same as having a decent one, and the author says underpaid or unsatisfactory work should be counted as a form of unemployment.
The argument starts with competition for government posts. Ministries and departments publish notifications almost every day, but universities and colleges across the states turn out graduates and postgraduates in such large numbers that a handful of openings can draw lakhs of applicants. Many people who cannot land those roles end up taking whatever work is available, and the piece says that makes them underemployed even if they technically have a paycheck.
The rural picture is more complicated. Farming has not disappeared, but fewer young people want to work the land. The author points to children from landowning families who take lower-paid government jobs in towns instead of modernising their own farms, even though they could hire workers and earn from the land themselves. At the same time, some farmers are adopting modern equipment, and that shift is starting to push joblessness into villages too.
On the headline numbers, the analysis notes that India's unemployment rate fell from 6.1 per cent in 2017-18 to 3.2 per cent in 2023-24. It also acknowledges a rise in the number of women workers over the past decade. But the author asks what kinds of jobs were created and under what conditions, saying those questions matter more than the totals.
The piece leans on the International Labour Organization's definition of decent work, which covers fair pay, workplace rights, social security and dignity. By that yardstick, the author says, a job without a contract, insurance or stable income does not fully count. The Periodic Labour Force Survey suggests working conditions have improved somewhat, and sectors such as agriculture, manufacturing, construction, trade and transport show some progress. Still, gains are uneven, and the author calls the overall picture troubling.
The analysis also calls for targeted action. Self-employed workers, farmers and daily-wage labourers without formal contracts need real protection rather than policies that look good only on paper. Women in the workforce need childcare support, safe transport and flexible arrangements, along with training and equal pay. The author argues that low wages meant to cut costs undermine dignity, and that the idea that certain jobs belong to one gender needs to go.
Why it matters: the way India measures jobs shapes which problems get attention. If a person earning too little for a stable life is still counted as employed, policy may miss the millions stuck in insecure work. The full analysis is available at The Hans India.